化妆品功效评价(Ⅴ)——舒缓功效宣称的科学支持

doi:10.13218/j.cnki.csdc.2018.05.002

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 概述了敏感性皮肤的表现和形成机制,介绍了物理化学法、生物化学法、细胞生物学法、三维重组皮肤模型替代法、动物实验法、主观评价法、半主观评价法、客观仪器评价法等舒缓化妆品功效的评价方法,提供了舒缓功效评价的新思路,展望了舒缓化妆品功效评价方法的未来发展方向。

关键词: 舒缓化妆品, 敏感性皮肤, 功效评价

Abstract: The performance and formation mechanism of sensitive skin were summarized.Various evaluation methods for soothing skin cosmetics such as physical and chemical methods,biochemical methods,cell biological methods,three dimensional recombinant skin model substitution method,animal experiment method,subjective evaluation,semi subjective evaluation and objective instrument evaluation method were introduced.The new idea of soothing efficacy evaluation was proposed and put forward the development direction of it.

Key words: soothing cosmetics, sensitive skin, efficacy evaluation

中图分类号:

TQ658

王欢, 盘瑶. 化妆品功效评价(Ⅴ)——舒缓功效宣称的科学支持[J]. 日用化学工业, 2018, 48(5): 247-254.

WANG Huan, PAN Yao. Efficacy evaluation of cosmetics (Ⅴ) Scientific support for soothing skin efficacy claims[J]. China Surfactant Detergent & Cosmetics, 2018, 48(5): 247-254.

参考文献

[1] He Li,Zheng Jie,Ma Hui-qun,et al.Expert consensus on sensitive skin diagnosis and treatment in China [J].Chinese Journal of Dermatovenereology,2017(1):1-4.
[2] Taieb C,Auges M,Georgescu V,et al.Sensitive skin in Brazil and Russia:An epidemiological and comparative approach [J].European Journal of Dermatology,2014,24(3):372-376.
[3] Yu Ling-ling,Wang Xue-min.Epidemiological investigation of sensitive skin in Shanghai [J].Clinical Journal of Dermatology,2011,40(7):403-406.
[4] Seidenari S,Francomano M,Mantovani L.Baseline biophysical parameters in subjects with sensitive skin [J].Contact Dermatitis,1998,38(6):311-315.
[5] Yokota T,Matsumoto M,Sakamaki T.Classification of sensitive skin and development of a treatment system appropriate for each group [J].IFSCC Mag,2003:4(6):303-307.
[6] Ständer S,Schneider S W,Weishaupt C,et al.Putative neuronal mechanisms of sensitive skin [J].Experimental Dermatology,2009,18(5):417-423.
[7] Querleux B,Dauchot K,Jourdain R,et al.Neural basis of sensitive skin:an fMRI study [J].Skin Research & Technology,2008,14(4):454-461.
[8] Laverdet B,Danigo A,Girard D,et al.Skin innervation:important roles during normal and pathological cutaneous repair[J].Histology & Histopathology,2015,30(8):875.
[9] Fan Lin-na.Study on the analysis of sensitive skin characteristic index and its evaluation method of repair activity [D].Beijing:Beijing Technology and Business University,2016.
[10] Zeng Jia-cong,Yang Jian.Skin horny layer ceramide detection method [J].Dermatology Clinic Journal,2014(2):159-161.
[11] Shan Lian-hai,Xiong Xiong,Guo Hai-xia.Preparation and application of hyaluronic acid [J].Anhui Agricultural Sciences,2007,35(11):3150-3151.
[12] Hu Guo-sheng.Determination of anti-inflammatory effects of various Chinese herbal ingredients using an in vitro inflammatory response model [C].Shanghai:China Cosmetics Symposium,2002.
[13] Li Jian-xi,Yang Zhi-qiang,Wang Xue-zhi.Biological effect of active oxygen radicals in animals [J].Progress in Animal Medicine,2006,27(10):33-36.
[14] Liao Yan,Wang Xue,Zhang Li-shi,et al.Hemolysis test as an alternative method to eye irritation test [J].Modern Preventive Medicine,2002,29(4):593-595.
[15] Fan L,He C,Jiang L,et al.Brief analysis of causes of sensitive skin and advances in evaluation of anti-allergic activity of cosmetic products [J].International Journal of Cosmetic Science,2016,38(2):120-127.
[16] Zhang Fang-fang.Effect of BaP combined with UVB on expression of Caspase-14 and Filaggrin in human keratinocytes [D].Tianjin:Tianjin Medical University,2013.
[17] Shan Shi-jun.Modulation of coix seed extract on Aquaporin-3 expression in HaCaT cells after UVB irradiation and its significance [D].Shenyang:China Medical University,2009.
[18] Zhao Dan.Effects of salicylic acid on expression of Filaggrin and Kallikrein-7 in human keratinocytes [D].Dalian:Dalian Medical University,2012.
[19] Wang Xi,Li Li.Skin keratin sticking technology and clinical application [J].Dermatological and Sexually Transmitted Diseases,2011,33(3):151-152.
[20] Hirao T,Denda M,Takahashi M.Identification of immature cornified envelopes in the barrier-impaired epidermis by characterization of their hydrophobicity and antigenicities of the components [J].Experimental Dermatology,2001,10(1):35-44.
[21] Xie Heng,Li Li,Xiong Li-Dan,et al.Comparison of skin barrier status and CE and KLK5 contents in facial dermatitis diseases [J].Journal of Sichuan University (Medical Science Edition),2013,44(6):940-944.
[22] Ci Hao-su.The difference of expression of substance P and calcitonin gene related peptide in normal and inflammatory gingival tissues [D].Shandong:Shandong University,2013.
[23] Li D G,Du H Y,Gerhard S,et al.Inhibition of TRPV1 prevented skin irritancy induced by phenoxyethanol.A preliminary in vitro and in vivo study [J].International Journal of Cosmetic Science,2017,39(1).
[24] Kueper T,Krohn M,Haustedt L O,et al.Inhibition of TRPV1 for the treatment of sensitive skin [J].Experimental Dermatology,2010,19(11):980-986.
[25] Du Shun-jing.Human cell line provocation test to detect chemical sensitization [D].Beijing:Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention,2009.
[26] Liu Hong,Zhou Bin,Chen Xin-sheng.Molecular biology of 5-lipoxygenase [J].Journal of Second Military Medical University,2004,25(10):1124-1126.
[27] Kong Xue,Zhao Hua,Tang Ying.Application of skin model in the evaluation of cosmetic efficacy [J].Daily Chemical Industry,2017,47(4):228-231.
[28] Ponec M,Kempenaar J.Use of human skin recombinants as an in vitro model for testing the irritation potential of cutaneous irritants [J].Skin Pharmacology & Physiology,1995,8(1/2):49-59.
[29] Bernhofer L P,Seiberg M,Martin K M.The influence of the response of skin equivalent systems to topically applied consumer products by epithelial-mesenchymal interactions [J].Toxicology in Vitro An International Journal Published in Association with Bibra,1999,13(2):219.
[30] Liang P P,Huang X Z,Yi J L,et al.A trichophyton rubrum infection model based on the reconstructed human Epidermis - Episkin^®[J].Chinese Medical Journal,2016,129(1):54-58.
[31] Andhare R N,Raut M K,Naik S R.Evaluation of antiallergic and anti-anaphylactic activity of ethanolic extract of Sansevieria trifasciata leaves (EEST) in rodents [J].Journal of Ethnopharmacology,2012,142(3):627-633.
[32] Bae M J,Shin H S,Choi D W,et al.Antiallergic effect of Trigonella foenum-graecum L.extracts on allergic skin inflammation induced by trimellitic anhydride in BALB/c mice [J].Journal of Ethnopharma-cology,2012,144(3):514-522.
[33] Singh B,Nadkarni J R,Vishwakarma R A,et al.The hydroalcoholic extract of Cassia alata (Linn.) leaves and its major compound rhein exhibits antiallergic activity via mast cell stabilization and lipoxygenase inhibition [J].Journal of Ethnopharmacology,2012,141(1):469.
[34] He Dan.Experimental study on the relationship between spleen deficiency and skin barrier function [D].Chengdu:Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine,2008.
[35] Wartewig S,Neubert R H H.Properties of ceramides and their impact on the stratum corneum structure:a review[J].Skin Pharmacol Physiol,2008,21(2):58-74.
[36] He Li,Guo Zhen-yu,Liu Hai-yang,et al.A functional skin care product containing Portulaca oleracea L.extract and its preparation method:CN 102764217A [P].2012-11-07.
[37] Zhang Hai-di,Dong Yin-mao,Meng Hong.Soothing formula effect on allergy and itching models [J].Chinese Journal of Experimental Formulae,2011,17(23):177-179.
[38] Wang Ling,Li Fu-heng.Study on anti-allergy and anti-pruritic effects of soothing formula extract [J].Journal of Qilu University of Technology (Natural Science Edition),2016,30(1):26-30.
[39] Zhang Jing-xia.Progress in the role of AQP3 in the pathogenesis of dermatoses [J].Medical Review,2013,19(17):3101-3103.
[40] Robinson M K,Cohen C,De F A B,et al.Non-animal testing strategies for assessment of the skin corrosion and skin irritation potential of ingredients and finished products [J].Food & Chemical Toxicology,2002,40(5):573-592.
[41] Wu Yan-yu,Wang Xue-min.Sensitive skin testing and assessment [J].Chinese Medical Aesthetics and Beauty Magazine,2003,9(4):249-251.
[42] Wan Jin-jin,Liu Rui-xue,Leng Yan-ying.Study on the efficacy of a sensitive skin cream [J].Chemicals for Daily Use,2017,40(11):24-28.
[43] Li Yong,Wen Xiang,Xian Yan,et al.Effect of soothing moisturizing repair cream in postoperative pulse laser treatment [J].Huaxi Medicine,2014(11):2155-2157.
[44] Li Yun,Sun Qiu-ning,Yang Rong-ya,et al.Therapeutic effect observation of 862 patients with facial sensitive skin treated with soothing special cream [J].Practical Journal of Dermatology,2015(2):85-88.
[45] Wu Yan,Du Li-xia,Chen Can,et al.Clinical effect of skincare products containing Portulaca oleracea L.and Butyrospermum parkii Kotschy tree extract on fat-free eczema [J].Clinical Journal of Dermatology,2009,38(6):349-351.
[46] Frosch P J,Duhring A M K.A method for appraising the stinging capacity of topically applied substances [J].Research,1977,28(5).
[47] Ohta M,Hikima R,Ogawa T.Physiological characteristics of sensitive skin classified by stinging test [J].Journal of Japanese Cosmetic Science Scoiety,2000,23(6):163-167.
[48] Lan Mao-xiang,Jeong Se Kyoo,Park Byeong Deog,et al.Sensitive skin and its countermeasures [J].Chinese Journal of Dermatology,2016,49(12):899-902.
[49] Jourdain R,Bastien P,De L O,et al.Detection thresholds of capsaicin:a new test to assess facial skin neurosensitivity [J].International Journal of Cosmetic Science,2005,56(3):153.
[50] Chen Shuang-yu,Wang Xue-min,Lin Yan-qun.Application of chemical probe test in sensitive skin evaluation [J].Clinical Journal of Dermatology,2014,43(3):190-193.
[51] Fu Yi-cai,Tan Yi-mei,Wang Xue-min.Sensitive skin and daily product development [J].Guangdong Chemical Industry,2015,42(16):148-150.
[52] Zhao Xin.Application of TEWL in evaluation of skin barrier function [J].Guangdong Chemical Industry,2014,41(14):133-134.
[53] Cao Jun,Zhu Xue-jun.The relationship between trans-epidermal water loss and the sex,age,anatomy of healthy people [J].Clinical Journal of Dermatology,2002,31(1):9-10.
[54] Hua Wei,Li Li.Electrical measurement of cuticle water content in skin [J].Chinese Journal of Dermatovenereology,2015(3):314-317.
[55] He Li.Skin barrier and moisturizer [J].Practical Hospital Clinical Journal,2009,6(2):25-27.
[56] Tao Rong,Niu Yue-qing,Guo Jian-min,et al.Subjective skin types and skin barrier function [J].Clinical Journal of Dermatology,2015(1):3-6.
[57] Ma Hui-jun,Zhu Wen-yuan.Skin surface acidity and its measurement method [J].Clinical Journal of Dermatology,2004,33(7):448-450.
[58] Thune P,Nilsen T,Hanstad I K,et al.The water barrier function of the skin in relation to the water content of stratum corneum,pH and skin lipids.The effect of alkaline soap and syndet on dry skin in elderly,non-atopic patients [J].Acta Derm Venereol,1988,68(4):277-283.
[59] Wu Yan.Regulation of oily skin and sebaceous gland secretion [J].Clinical Journal of Dermatology,2004,33(12):769-771.